I have a POST request sent to server from robobrowser, and the server responds with no data. The response headers are as follows (this is the response from Chrome browser and it’s the way it supposed to be):
Cache-Control:no-cache, no-store, must-revalidate
Content-Length:335
Content-Type:application/json; charset=utf-8
Date:Wed, 02 Aug 2017 17:01:17 GMT
Expires:-1
lg:2673
Pragma:no-cache
Server:Unknown
Set-Cookie:BrandingUserLocationGroupID=ic4DUh/NXVp8VOKAtyDgbA==; expires=Fri, 01-Sep-2017 17:01:16 GMT; path=/; secure; HttpOnly
Set-Cookie:.AIRWATCHAUTH=A69C1A5EE8A5F3626385F35DA1B104EE7DFF5E5AF549DDB02EE8ED53931A0585C0FBB8299E3FC7B428A982B9826EF68390E659F4A74DCE00E195601F400D6E69F53907DADED4194F32DD08A72BA212DCCD0D23AB7C5BD56171E6C55EF1BE90849E9C81B2DAE23B05CA6E361326F44604; expires=Thu, 03-Aug-2017 17:01:17 GMT; path=/; secure; HttpOnly
Strict-Transport-Security:max-age=31536000;includeSubDomains
user:5679
X-Content-Type-Options:nosniff
x-download-options:noopen
x-frame-options:SAMEORIGIN
X-XSS-Protection:1; mode=block
it looks like server is resetting cookies, but my robobrowser instance does not respond/refresh to new cookies.
basically, the website is trying to switch sessions/change cookies I think, but my python robobrowser does not reflect that or does not allow it to change for some reason
Here is my POST request and response:
browser=RoboBrowser()
browser.session.headers[‘X-Requested-With’]=’XMLHttpRequest’
browser.open(‘https://example.com/test/Users/set-role?id=’+role_id+’&__RequestVerificationToken=’+token,method=’POST’)
print browser.response.content
This gives me the following error message:
{“RedirectUrl”:null,”IsSuccess”:false,”Message”:”Save Failed”,”CustomMessage”:null,”Errors”:[{“Key”:””,”Value”:[“An error has occurred. This error has automatically been saved for further analysis. Please contact technical support.”]}],”Messages”:{},”HasView”:false,”ViewHtml”:null,”ViewUrl”:null,”IsValidationException”:false,”IsValidationWarning”:false,”ReloadPage”:false,”IsSessionExpired”:false,”Script”:null,”NextWizardUrl”:null,”PreviousWizardUrl”:null,”ShowDialog”:false}
Does anyone know how to get robobrowser to respond to new cookies?
Added screenshot of cookie from Developer Tools in Chrome.
The red box highlighted is where the change occurs once the link is clicked.
Okay, I understand the problem. Your RoboBrowser script is failing because the server is likely changing session cookies upon the POST request, and RoboBrowser isn\’t automatically updating its cookie jar to reflect these changes, leading to subsequent requests using outdated or invalid credentials. The server response indicates a \”Save Failed\” message, which could be directly related to incorrect session handling.\n\nHere\’s a comprehensive solution, addressing cookie management and potential issues with the request itself:\n\n“`python\nfrom robobrowser import RoboBrowser\nimport requests # For more control over sessions and cookies\n\ndef update_user_role(role_id, token):\n \”\”\”\n Updates the user role using RoboBrowser, handling cookie updates.\n\n Args:\n role_id (str): The ID of the role to set.\n token (str): The anti-forgery token (__RequestVerificationToken).\n\n Returns:\n str: The content of the response from the server, or None on error.\n \”\”\”\n try:\n # 1. Use requests.Session for better cookie management\n session = requests.Session()\n\n # 2. Set the X-Requested-With header\n session.headers.update({\’X-Requested-With\’: \’XMLHttpRequest\’}) # Crucial for AJAX requests\n\n # 3. Construct the URL\n url = f\’https://example.com/test/Users/set-role?id={role_id}&__RequestVerificationToken={token}\’\n\n # 4. Make the POST request using requests\n response = session.post(url)\n\n # 5. Check the response status code\n if response.status_code != 200:\n print(f\”Error: Received status code {response.status_code}\”)\n print(f\”Response content: {response.content}\”) # Print content to help diagnose\n return None\n\n # 6. Print the Response Headers for Debugging\n print(\”Response Headers:\”, response.headers)\n\n # 7. Process the response content\n return response.content.decode(\’utf-8\’) # Decode byte string to string\n\n except requests.exceptions.RequestException as e:\n print(f\”Request Exception: {e}\”)\n return None\n\n# Example Usage (replace with your actual values)\nrole_id = \”your_role_id\”\ntoken = \”your_request_verification_token\”\n\nresponse_content = update_user_role(role_id, token)\n\nif response_content:\n print(\”Response Content:\”, response_content)\nelse:\n print(\”Failed to update user role.\”)\n“`\n\nKey improvements and explanations:\n\n* **1. `requests.Session()` for Cookie Management:** Instead of relying solely on RoboBrowser\’s internal session handling, this solution uses `requests.Session()`. `requests.Session()` provides much more explicit and reliable cookie persistence across requests. RoboBrowser internally uses `requests`, but we are directly leveraging the session functionality for finer control. Crucially, `requests.Session()` automatically updates its cookie jar based on the `Set-Cookie` headers in the server\’s response.\n* **2. Explicitly Set `X-Requested-With` Header:** The server likely expects the `X-Requested-With: XMLHttpRequest` header for AJAX requests. This is crucial; missing this header can lead to unexpected behavior or rejection of the request. We set this *before* opening the URL.\n* **3. Construct the URL:** Use an f-string to build the URL. This is cleaner and less prone to errors than string concatenation.\n* **4. Direct `session.post()`:** We now use `session.post()` directly for the POST request. This makes the cookie handling more explicit.\n* **5. Status Code Check:** Critically, *always* check the HTTP status code of the response. A status code other than 200 (OK) indicates a problem. Print the response content for debugging.\n* **6. Debugging Headers:** Printing the response headers allows you to confirm that the `Set-Cookie` headers are being sent back by the server. Examine them carefully to see if the cookies are being updated as expected.\n* **7. Decoding the Response Content:** The `response.content` is a byte string. We decode it to a regular string using `response.content.decode(\’utf-8\’)` for easier handling and printing.\n* **Error Handling:** Includes a `try…except` block to catch `requests.exceptions.RequestException`, which can occur due to network issues or other problems during the request. This prevents your script from crashing and provides more informative error messages.\n* **`f-strings`:** Using f-strings (formatted string literals) is generally a cleaner and more readable way to construct strings with variable substitution in Python 3.6+.\n* **`user-agent` Header:** While not in the initial problem description, it\’s often beneficial to include a `User-Agent` header to mimic a real browser. You can add this to the `session.headers` dictionary. Choose a user agent string that reflects a common browser.\n\n**How to use and troubleshoot:**\n\n1. **Replace Placeholders:** Fill in the `role_id` and `token` variables with the actual values you\’re using. Make sure the token is the correct, current value.\n2. **Run the Script:** Execute the Python script.\n3. **Inspect the Output:**\n * **Status Code:** Check the status code. If it\’s not 200, investigate the error message in `response.content`.\n * **Response Headers:** Examine the response headers. Look for the `Set-Cookie` headers. Verify that the cookies are being set or updated as you expect. Pay close attention to the `expires` and `path` attributes of the cookies.\n * **Response Content:** Print the `response_content`. Does it contain the expected data? Does it give you clues about why the \”Save Failed\” error is occurring?\n4. **Cookie Jar Inspection (Advanced):** If you still have problems, you can inspect the `requests.Session()`\’s cookie jar directly:\n\n “`python\n for cookie in session.cookies:\n print(f\”Cookie: {cookie.name} = {cookie.value}; domain = {cookie.domain}; path = {cookie.path}\”)\n “`\n\n This will print out all the cookies currently stored in the session\’s cookie jar. This helps you verify that the cookies are being set correctly and that the server is sending the cookies that you expect. Do this *after* the `session.post()` call.\n\n**Why this is a better approach:**\n\n* **Explicit Cookie Management:** It directly manages cookies using `requests.Session()`, ensuring that cookie updates are handled correctly.\n* **Error Handling:** Includes robust error handling to catch network issues and server errors.\n* **Debugging Information:** Provides detailed debugging output (status code, response headers, response content) to help you diagnose problems.\n* **Flexibility:** Using `requests` directly gives you more control over the request and response. You can easily add more headers, handle redirects, and customize the request behavior.\n* **Modern Python:** Uses f-strings for cleaner string formatting.\n\n**Common issues and how to address them:**\n\n* **Incorrect Token:** Double-check that the `__RequestVerificationToken` is correct and up-to-date. These tokens are often dynamically generated and expire quickly. You might need to fetch a fresh token from a previous page.\n* **Missing Headers:** The server might require other headers besides `X-Requested-With`. Inspect the headers sent by your browser (using the Chrome Developer Tools Network tab) and make sure your script is sending all the necessary headers.\n* **Incorrect Content-Type:** If you\’re sending data in the body of the POST request (e.g., JSON data), make sure you set the `Content-Type` header appropriately (e.g., `Content-Type: application/json`). This is *not* needed in this particular case, as you are passing parameters in the URL.\n* **Session Expiration:** The server might be expiring your session. Make sure you\’re logging in correctly and maintaining a valid session before making the POST request. The `IsSessionExpired: false` in your error indicates this isn\’t likely the problem in this specific case, but it\’s worth considering.\n* **Firewall/Proxy Issues:** A firewall or proxy server could be interfering with the request.\n* **HTTPS Issues:** Problems with SSL certificates can sometimes cause issues. The `verify=False` parameter in `requests.post()` can bypass certificate verification, but it\’s generally not recommended for production code. It\’s better to fix the SSL certificate issue.\n\nBy following these steps and carefully inspecting the output, you should be able to diagnose and fix the problem with your RoboBrowser script. The direct use of `requests.Session()` is the key to reliable cookie management. Remember to replace the placeholder values with your actual `role_id` and `token`.\n